Independent Contractor or Employee: What's the Difference, Pros and Cons

Whether you’re looking for new talent to join a big company or you’re a small entrepreneur trying to expand your own business, hiring people can feel like walking on a tightrope. You must balance labor laws, budgets, qualifications, soft skills, and deadlines, among many factors, in order to get the desired result. 

However, one question often goes unnoticed for companies during this process: Should I hire an independent contractor or an employee? A key question that flies over the heads of many HR managers. It might seem like a small detail, but any misclassified worker can lead to serious legal troubles or unexpected economic costs, especially when hiring overseas.

With this guide, we'll help you understand the differences between employees and independent contractors. Comprehending all the nuances, pros, and cons will help you make an informed decision about the right choice for your business.

What Is an Independent Contractor?

Independent contractors are hired by companies to work on a project or to deliver results on a time-based basis. However, they operate autonomously and have a relatively high degree of control. Independent contractors set their own hours of work, decide how to complete their tasks, and often use their own tools and equipment.

Understanding what an independent contractor is essential before making any kind of comparison to any other type of worker. In the U.S., the Internal Revenue Service (IRS), the Department of Labor, the Fair Labor Standards Act, and the common law have largely set guidelines about this concept for years.

Independent contractors can be hired in America or internationally. For example, with Lupa Hire you can get the best talent in LatAm for 70% less. However, here one concept shines above any other, no matter the actual location: self-employment.

This independent contractor status offers more flexibility for both parties, and it's quite common for roles such as consultants, developers, and designers. Think of it as a flexible way to hire specialized service providers for short-term projects without making them full-time members of your staff.

Differences between Employee and Independent Contractor

‍

Even though it may not be fully clear at first sight, understanding the differences between employees and independent contractors is important to assemble the best possible team. 

With the following list, you can easily comprehend how they compare:

Employees

• They normally work a pre-established number of hours per week, set in a written contract.
• They often work at a company office or in a different, designed location according to the business' needs.
• They receive a regular salary or hourly wage. The amount must comply at least with the minimum wage.
• They have access to or are at least eligible for employee benefits such as health insurance, retirement plans, and paid time off.
• Employers withhold taxes from each paycheck. These taxes correspond to Social Security, Medicare, and federal/state/local income taxes.
• They are covered by workers' compensation laws.

Independent Contractors

• They control when, where, and how they work. They manage their own schedule.
• Independent contractors can work remotely from home or from any other location they choose, including home-based locations in LatAm.
• They receive payment per milestone, task, or project. There is no salary.
• Independent contractors typically do not receive employee benefits.
• They are fully responsible for handling their own tax obligations, including any self-employment tax.
• They aren't covered by unemployment insurance, employee protections, or compensation laws.

Employees vs. Independent Contractors: Key Legal and Financial Differences

Classifying workers as either employees or independent contractors goes way beyond a simple act of administrative formality. Setting the correct worker status for each member of your team is crucial to managing payrolls, taxes, and legal responsibilities, especially in the U.S.

Let's explore these outcomes a bit further:

• Avoid misclassification: The American government monitors worker classifications very closely. Therefore, business owners must be extremely careful from the very beginning. Any infringement can lead to legal trouble and heavy penalties from labor authorities.
• Tax compliance: Employers must withhold and pay different types of taxes (medicare taxes, social security taxes, federal tax) for employees. On the contrary, independent contractors are solely responsible for handling their own taxes. Mixing this up can lead to audits and fines.
• Benefits and protections: Workers with employee status are entitled to several benefits and legal protections like overtime pay, unemployment coverage, and minimum wage. Independent contractors aren't. Any confusion in this sense can lead to serious problems and affect the employment relationship.
• Different workplace regulations: There are some specific workplace regulations, such as safety standards and anti-discrimination laws, that apply to employees. These rules are set to create and keep a fair work environment. Independent contractors are not affected by these regulations.
• More profitability: Hiring standard employees is a costly process, involving more expenditures and higher financial risks. With international contractors, you can avoid many costs, such as training programs and office equipment. This can result in huge savings, especially with Lupa Hire, where U.S. companies can have access to the best talent in LatAm for 70% less.

Differences between an Independent Contractor and an International Contractor

At the moment of looking for an independent contractor, the search for the best talent may lead you to hire an international contractor. Even though this figure will still offer flexibility, there are some specific considerations around legal, financial, and compliance matters attached to this working relationship.

Let's explore further in this section:

Legal Obligations and Compliance

International contractors are subject to the laws of their own country. Therefore, contractor agreements, payment terms, and additional conditions will be different in comparison to the legal framework of a regular employee, who must comply with national laws. Companies must understand these complexities and act accordingly.

Partners such as Lupa Hire will be a great help to navigate local labor laws in LatAm to ensure compliance.

Tax Implications

Typically, U.S. companies aren't required to withhold taxes from international contractors. Any kind of tax withholding or tax payment is a responsibility of the contractor. 

Payment Process

Traditional payments for a local contractor are quite easy and straightforward, involving standard domestic transfers.

Payments for international contractors include some additional complexities. Currency exchange rates, international wire transfers, longer payment timelines… Both the worker and the payer must be fully aware of these particularities. 

Lupa Hire can assist you in this process, facilitating payments for workers in LatAm.

Lowering Expenses

By accessing a bigger talent pool, businesses can access top-tier professionals at more competitive rates. It's a great way for established businesses to scale their workforce and expand their team without the administrative work and the associated costs of full-time employment status.

For example, with Lupa Hire you can reduce the hiring costs up to 70% in comparison to a standard hire in the U.S.

Why U.S Companies Are Deciding to Hire International Contractors

To gain a competitive edge in today's market, U.S. companies are consistently turning to international contractors. Considered as a business trend by some people, it's actually a smart move to help teams grow faster with top talent in a cost-efficient way.

Access to a Broader Talent Pool

Instead of being limited to the local talent market, U.S. companies with specific business needs can access specialized talent with a wider range of skills and knowledge. Whether they need a web designer or a software developer, American companies can quickly find the best person for the project, no matter where they are.

With Lupa Hire, you can select the best workers in LatAm to drive innovation and reach success.

Lowering Expenses

With international contractors, you don't have to assume many of the expenses established by local and federal laws associated with a traditional employer-employee relationship.

You can avoid the costs of training programs, office equipment, and employee benefits, among others. Additionally, varying market rates can lead to generally lower labor expenses.

Flexibility and Scalability

Whether you need to scale up your workforce in order to launch a new project or you need to scale it down due to rapidly changing market conditions, international contractors offer you an agility that cannot be found in traditional hiring due to the administrative and legal burden of local hiring.

This approach helps to keep operations efficient and adaptable without much delay.

Common Roles of Independent Contractors

Independent contractors are normally associated by the general public with a variety of roles across several industries, being typically hired to participate and complete certain tasks or projects.

To understand the full scope of this work figure, let's display a list of some examples:

• Graphic designers: Key role for business branding, marketing, and website design.
• Developers: Participate in software teams or work independently in order to make apps, websites, or internal tools.
• Marketing experts: Help plan and execute marketing strategies or ad campaigns.
• Product & Project Management: They act as overseers for the development and launch of specific projects. They plan, organize, and manage resources to guarantee results are delivered on time and within the assigned budget.
• Data & Analytics: Their expertise is essential to extracting valuable insights from raw data. Their analysis and forecasts help companies make data-driven decisions.
• Artificial Intelligence experts: With the current rise of AI technology, they help companies incorporate AI solutions to internal systems and processes, thus favoring innovation and competitiveness.

This is just an example of the dozens of jobs where you can find professionals participating in the global economy as independent contractors.

As competitiveness in the global market leads to a higher demand for more flexible and scalable solutions, the figure of the independent contractor keeps rising to a predominant role in the labor market. And the trend doesn't seem to be reversed quite soon.

Whether you need to hire independent contractors or employees, Lupa Hire simplifies the process of recruiting, staffing and RPO. Access top talent globally, ensure compliance with local regulations, and manage payroll seamlessly. Build your team your way.

FAQs

What Are the Tax Implications of Being an Independent Contractor vs. an Employee?

Here, the responsibility changes sides. Normally, employees have taxes withheld by their employer. But for independent contractors, they are responsible for self-employment taxes.

What Are the Legal Implications of Classifying a Worker As an Independent Contractor Instead of an Employee?

This action can result in fines and penalties from labor authorities, with serious financial consequences.

What Are the Benefits and Drawbacks of Hiring Independent Contractors vs. Employees?

Benefits: cost-effectiveness, flexibility, access to specialized skills. Drawbacks: less control, potential compliance issues, and lack of employee loyalty/benefits.

What Are the Differences between an Independent Contractor and an International Contractor?

Independent contractors are self-employed individuals, while international contractors are workers located in different countries and subject to a different legal framework, also with different tax regulations.

What Are the Pros and Cons of Hiring International Contractors?

Pros: access to global talent, cost savings, flexibility. With Lupa Hire’s staffing and hiring solutions, you can get the best professionals in LatAm for less money, without all the hassle of traditional recruitment.

Cons: compliance complexity, time zone differences, and potential communication difficulties.